Every UM leader knows the frustration: a payer feels difficult to work with, denials feel too frequent, but there’s no data to prove it or to decide where to spend limited time and energy. Health systems using Xsolis’ real-time data and analytics can replace that anecdote with evidence, changing not just the outcome of individual disputes, but the shape of the payer relationship itself.
Follow the five steps below to make the shift.
1. Build the Baseline: Rank Your Payers Using Data2. Use the Scorecard to Prioritize Interventions3. Let the Data Do the Talking in the Room4. Find Common Ground: Locate Where Both Sides Are Wasting Resource5. Formalize the Win and Keep the Discipline
HealthPartners used this exact approach to identify a payer with a denial rate five times higher than any other in its market, and to negotiate gold card status with several payers. The health system has since created roles focused solely on payer strategy, a sign of how far a data-driven approach can shift priorities.
Most UM teams struggle to quantify avoidable denials, which makes payer discussions unproductive. Using Xsolis data to “rank” payers isn’t about keeping a scorecard for its own sake. It’s about tracking the analytics that matter (e.g., denial rates, peer-to-peer win rates, and appeal turnaround by payer) and building a payer strategy on concrete numbers instead of impressions.
An example: a UM team walked into a meeting with a payer armed with an anecdote and no data. The payer pushed back, correctly, that two physician impressions weren’t evidence. Months later, the same team returned with a data-backed scorecard showing the payer’s denial rate was approximately five times higher than the next-highest payer in the market. The payer’s own team leaned in and acknowledged the gap.
The scorecard turns “we think” into “we know,” which is the precondition for every step that follows.
Not every issue deserves the same level of attention, so use the ranked data to prioritize interventions. Which payer relationship has the highest denial rate, the most reviewer time consumed, or the most revenue at risk?
Pilot this data-backed approach with a smaller or lower-market-share payer first (lower risk, easier to test), then use that proof point to make the case for tackling larger, more difficult payer relationships.
Over time, UM teams that build this discipline move from reacting payer by payer to a proactive approach built on data and focused on overall payer relationships rather than isolated behaviors.
At HealthPartners, this kind of year-over-year discipline helped bring one major payer’s denial rate down from 6% to 1%.
Coming armed with data and evidence reframes discussions from adversarial (“your denial rate is too high”) to fact-finding (“your denial rate is five times the next payer’s, walk me through that”). Data doesn’t just shift the discussion. It builds a foundation of trust between both parties.
And these discussions shouldn’t be one-off occurrences. Establishing a regular meeting cadence with specific payers to share performance data may accelerate both groups’ willingness to change behaviors that aren’t beneficial.
In a sense, it’s catching up to how payers have long measured hospitals, then flipping the lens so the health system is measuring, and educating, the payer in return
Instead of framing the issue as “denials are too high,” frame it as “we’re both spending time on cases that don’t need it.”
One alternative to the typical back-and-forth of peer-to-peer reviews: gold card (auto-approve) status for case categories the health system consistently wins, in exchange for still sending every gray/complex case for review.
Some case types are reviewed heavily but rarely change the outcome. A data-backed look at review accuracy can justify redirecting that review time to higher-value work.
This isn’t a negotiating trick. It’s math both sides can independently verify, which is why it holds up.
Both gold card agreements and dedicated payer strategy roles are initiatives that would have been nearly impossible for HealthPartners to pursue without the reliable, ongoing data foundation that Xsolis provides.
Once one payer relationship improves this way, the same data and pitch can be reused with other payers in the market. In some cases, a payer’s own clinical leadership will even advocate the approach to their peers.
But the work doesn’t stop there.
The scorecard should be continuously refreshed and used to prioritize both improvement opportunities and negotiation points. New data points, not just the denial rate, should be brought into these payer discussions as the relationship matures.
1. Rank payers with data, not gut feelings
2. Prioritize interventions off the ranking
3. Ground every conversation in evidence, changing the dynamic, not just the outcome
4. Look for shared waste, not just one-sided wins, that’s what actually gets a “yes”
615+ hospital clients
850+ established payer connections
25 national health plan partnerships
Xsolis’ AI-driven platform, Dragonfly, provides real-time reporting and analytics that offer payer- and denial-level visibility. Using the reporting, health systems can dig into denial rates, peer-to-peer win rates, appeal turnaround, and more, all broken out by payer. A dedicated Xsolis team supports the partnership throughout, making sure health system clients get what they need from their data.
With 615+ hospital clients and 850+ established payer connections across 25 national health plan partnerships, Xsolis brings that same depth of experience to the real-time reporting and analytics behind it.
Reach out for a consultation today.